Houdini Fights Film Expose of Illusion Part 2 of 2

The “major illusion” to which Houdini refers in his letter [shared in Part 1] is that of “Sawing a Woman in Half.

Below is the second part of the Billboard article from my personal collection:

GOLDIN GETS INJUNCTION

Horace Goldin, who for the past season presented “Sawing a Woman in Half” for the Keith interests, this week secured a temporary restraining order against Weiss Brothers, producers of the expose film. Hearing on a motion to make the injunction permanent is slated for some time next week.

In his application for an injunction Goldin set forth that he is the inventor of the “Sawing a Woman in Half” Illusion and holds patents to substantiate his claim. He also alleges that the billing matter, captions and sub-titles used in the picture are an infringement on his own.

The illusion exposed, is not that of Goldin’s, but a depiction of the version of which P. T. Selbit, and English magician, claims to be the inventor. The effect, however, of both the Goldin and Selbit versions is held to be identical.

Goldin was recently granted an injunction against the Alexander Film Co., which concern also produced an expose of the illusion in question. Goldin estimates that he has been obliged to spend upward of $15000 during the past season in litigation to protest his illusion.

The Rialto Theater, where the illusion is booked to show, has been served with notice of the injunction against the producers.

BONUS

Houdini’s “Slicing of a Woman” Apparatus

October 15, 1926 Schenectady NY Gazette describes Houdini’s slicing of a woman:

The slicing of a woman, a trick derived from the ancient torture machines of China, is one of the big features of the first act. With the aid of assistants, Houdini places a young woman in a casket. Several knives are suspended above her body. The blades descend at a fast rate and seemingly slice the body of the girl. But when the casket is opened she steps out from the box, bows, and makes her exit none the worse for the experience.

HHCE highlights from Magic Collectors Expo 2022 and Harry Ransom Center

Wednesday April 13, 2022

4pm – Rode over to Harry Ransom Center (HRC) with Houdini Collector Dr. Bruce Averbook of Ohio, who shared some photos from his museum he is working on. BTW, next year’s Magic Collector’s Expo (MCE) will feature his museum. Can’t wait!

4:30pm – 5:30 Dr. Eric Colleary put together a fantastic Houdini exhibit (2 glass showcases of Houdini ephemera, plus a one sheet Man from Beyond Poster) just for the Expo and gave a well-received presentation on the HRC and how it obtained the Houdini collection.

5:30pm – 6pm Rode over to Esther’s Follies with HH aka  Harlan Hogan.

6pm – 9:30pm Got to enjoy “the greatest entertainment experience in Texas”, Esther’s Follies Special Dinner & Show for Magic Collector’s Expo. “It’s comedy, magic, music & historical fun!”

9:30pm Rode back with Gary Hunt (website: handcuffqueens.com) and discussed the book, Houdini’s Zanetti Mystery that I published at the beginning of the year.

Thursday April 14, 2022

9am – 9:30pm Entered the Dealer Room at the MCE and made the rounds. Houdini Collector’s Ken Trombly and Roger Dreyer had dealer tables.

Bought an original White Studio, NY “Man From Beyond” Still from Ken Trombly.

Chatted with Roger Dreyer about “Q” from the Master Mystery and NFTs.

10am – 4pm Got to enjoy “the greatest Houdini experience in Texas”, HRC.

Went back to HRC to do research on Harry Houdini’s film career. This included containers with ephemera on the Famous Players-Lasky Corporation (The Grim Game Stills, Terror Island Ads), Film Developing Corporation/Weehawken Street Corporation (Financial statements, correspondence, taxes 1921-1925), Houdini Picture Corporation (Haldane and Man From Beyond stills), Mystery Picture Corporation (Business and Administration, plus info on  Ashes of Passion, original film title Il Mistero di Osiris [The Mystery of the Jewel] later renamed Reincarnation), and Octagon Film Corporation (The Master Mystery Scene Plots and Scripts).

6pm-7pm Ran into Gary Hunt at TexMex restaurant in town and shared my day at HRC.

7pm – 8:30pm Attended MCE.  Randy Pitchford (who purchased the Magic Castle) introduced Neppy, Ricky Jay’s Automaton, which he had John Gaughan restore.

Lance Burton & Fielding West shared reflections and stories on one of the greatest gatherings of magicians in the world (Harry Anderson, Lance Burton, Doug Henning, Harry Blackstone Jr., Siegfried & Roy, John Thompson, Fielding West, Jeff McBride, Mark Wilson, and Max Maven) for a stage spectacular of magic to benefit a very worthy cause.

8:30pm – 11pm Dealer Room Open

Purchased from Kent Cummins a red-tone cover variant of the black-tone cover Lee Jacobs reproduction “Houdini Souvenir Program”.

Friday April 15, 2022

10am – 1pm Went back to HRC to wrap-up research on Harry Houdini’s film career. This included over-sized folders and boxes with original posters (Man From Beyond, Milk Can, WTC, Vanishing Elephant), title cards (Grim Game, Man From Beyond, Master Mystery) and lobby cards (Man From Beyond).

2:30-4pm Attended Session#4 at the MCE. David Charvet introduced his latest book, “The Great Jester” Kent Cummins shared the story of making a tree appear on top of a new building being erected, and Gabe Fajuri introduced Steve Cohen’s new book on Malini.

7pm-8:30pm Attended MCE “Magic of Austin Show” which was very entertaining.

Thank you to Bill Smith and all his helpers for putting on an amazing Expo.

And thank you to Dr. Eric Colleary and Michael Gilmore at the Harry Ransom Center for being so helpful with my Houdini research and making this trip extra special.

Related:

Houdini Fights Film Expose of Major Illusion Part 1 of 2

Today, I share the first part of a Billboard article from my personal collection that includes a letter from Houdini.

New York April 15, 1922 – The Society of American Magicians, thru its president, Harry Houdini issued a direct appeal to theater managers all over the country to aid in its campaign to suppress magical expose. This step was taken after it became known that a motion picture disclosing the secrets of a major illusion had been placed on the market and had been booked for a showing in a Broadway picture theater.

Mr. Houdini’s communication to the managers of the country read:

The Society of American Magicians numbers one thousand members , and we, individually and collectively, are trying to suppress the expose of magic and illusions. We magicians have a hard enough time inventing and creating new ideas, and it is an injustice for anyone, for any reason whatsoever, to expose the mysteries of our protection.

We ask you, as a body, please not to present any film exposing the mysteries to the public, and you, as a showman, know it is unethical, unprofessional, and far from belonging to the decorum of any gentleman in any stage of life to deliberately, either for gain or revenge, injure another’s profession.

We understand that a certain film exposing a major illusion is seeking bookings, which prompts our addressing this letter to you,

(Signed) HARRY HOUDINI

In two weeks, I will share the rest of the article, which explains what major illusion Houdini is referring to.

Next week, I am off to the Magic Collectors Expo and the Harry Ransom Center in Austin Texas.