Pick a Date

Last November, I did a blog about when were some handcuff photos taken?

There was some discussion about when the following famous photo was taken that focused mainly on 1903 or 1904.

Frank Koval photo

At the end of the day, we thought Houdini got it right and it was taken in March 1904 during his engagement at the London Hippodrome.

If that is the case, then how do we explain this rookie card of Harry Houdini from 1902.

houdini-ogdens-front

So, the pictorial credits in “Notes to Houdini!! By Ken Silverman may have been correct.

1903 Morris Young Collection

They state that even though Houdini’s handwritten note on the photo above in the Morris Young collection says 1903, the identical photo in the Carrandi collection,shown on p. 2 has been dated 1900, by either Houdini or Bess.

Although the image shown on p.2 (similar left image below) is not quite the same.

1903 Handcuff Photos from Original H Scrapbook

So we have now ruled out 1903 and 1904, unless the 1902 date on the rookie card is wrong?

HOUDINI THE GREAT Story Treatment Part II

Continuation of HOUDINI THE GREAT Story Treatment by Frank O’Connor and Dore Schary, dated January 3, 1936:

Do Spirits ReturnThat night at the show, thousands of people have crowded into the theatre to listen to the startling expose that Houdini has promised.

Houdini is back stage making preparations for his Chinese torture cell trick.

Houdini tells his assistants that he will perform the trick after his talk and expose.

Houdini goes to his dressing room to prepare himself for his appearance. When he gets to his dressing room, a figure of a man clothed in black hat and coat approaches him.  He tells Houdini that he is here to convince him, that he, Houdini, must not give his message tonight.

The man takes a gun from his pocket; Houdini rushes him and the man fires and Houdini staggers under the impact of the bullet which hits him in the stomach.  There is a sound of another shot and the black garbed man falls into the shadows of the curtained corner.

The door is opened by a group of excited people who want to know what has happened.  Houdini doesn’t say that he has been wounded.  He merely, says – I’ve seen a man kill himself – for his God.

Houdini, still not telling anyone that he has been wounded, goes out on the stage and gives his message to the audience.

He tells them that the subject of the message has been slightly altered due to something he has suddenly learned.

He tells them that there is a God, that they must believe that. He tells them that there is a hereafter and they must believe that too. And he says that they must not believe those crooked and ruthless charlatans who bleed them in the misled hope that they can establish contact with the spiritual world.

He tells them that someday they will all learn the secret but that they will not learn it from fakers who produce phony hands and spooky voices form wired chambers.

And after his speech, he prepares for his trick, a dangerous ordeal which he accomplishes successfully.

After he gets out of the cell at the conclusion of his act, he staggers and falls to the floor.  The curtain is rung down as the audience applauds and cheers wildly. Bess and Powers and some others rush to Houdini. He tells them that he has been hurt – that he is dying.

Bess holds him in her arms.  He tells her not to be frightened – that someday, somewhere, they will see each other again.  He tells her that someday she, too, will learn the secret he is learning now but she will never learn until her time has come.

He tells them all that they must believe in God and that he is happy that he has found out the truth before he died.

THE END!

79 Years Ago Today – HOUDINI THE GREAT Story Treatment Part I

I thought I would start the New Year by sharing a couple paraphrased parts of a Story Treatment titled HOUDINI THE GREAT by Frank O’Connor and Dore Schary, dated January 3, 1936

Buzz Saw Houdini

 

Bess gives birth to a baby boy but it dies at the same time Houdini frees himself from the buzz saw escape.

 

Later on in the treatment…

 

Bess is taken. Houdini is told that if he will agree to cancel his proposed unmasking of the spiritualists, his wife will be returned to him safe and sound, but if he goes through with his plans, his wife will be in serious danger.

Houdini, stalling, asks for some proof that his wife is still alive and he is told that he will receive a message from her in the form of a letter which will indicate to him that she is all right.

The following morning, Houdini receives a note from Bess.  It is apparently a simple, straight-forward note, telling him that she is well and that he should do whatever he thinks best.  However, this note employs the use of many of the words used in the mind-reading code that Bess and Houdini had worked years ago during the vaudeville days.

Houdini gets the significance of the message which tells him very plainly where she is being held. Houdini contacts the police and Bess is liberated and the spiritualists are apprehended.

TO BE CONTINUED…

 

Mystery Pictures Corporation

93 Years Ago Today, December 27, 1921, Houdini became the figurehead of The Mystery Pictures Corporation.  Note:  This is not the Houdini Picture Corporation (HPC), nor the Film Developing Corporation (FDC) which wishes you all A Merry Christmas and A Happy and Prosperous New Year

from Exhibitors Trade Review magazine

FDC: Houdini invested in the FDC in 1916.  It was founded upon a novel invention: a method of automated film processing, developed by Gustav Dietz. Offices were opened on Broadway, and a factory in Hoboken, New Jersey.  Houdini’s initial investment was $4,900 but the company was never able to turn a profit.  In April, 1918, Houdini fired Dietz and attempted to improve upon the mechanism himself, assigning his brother, Theodore W. Hardeen, to run the company, all to no avail.

HPC Stock Certificate dated June 1921

HPC: It seemed only natural that, owning a film processing company, he should make his own films, rather than relying on the resources and expertise of a motion picture studio. He formed the Houdini Picture Corporation (HPC) in early in 1921. By October of 1921, seven months after incorporating HPC, Houdini had wrapped up two full-length feature films, The Man From Beyond and Haldane.

Even though The Moving Picture World had announced that the HPC would produce “four feature productions a year, in which Houdini will be the star,” the filmmakers must have quickly realized how impossible it would be to live up to this ambition.  So Houdini sought other ways to keep the FDC busy, and to shore up his film-making empire.

The Mystery Pictures Corporation was formed.

During his tours through Europe, he had discovered that there were many high-quality films there that might never be exported to the U.S.  What they lacked in popular American stars, they made up for in production values.  Harry Houdini was the President.  Hardeen was vice president and Harry H. Poppe served as Secretary.

Soul of Bronze PosterFilms imported for distribution included: 1918 French Film L’Ame du bronze (Soul of Bronze), Les Contes de mille et une nuits (A Thousand and One Nights), and 1919 Italian Film II mistero di Osiris (The Mystery of the Jewel).  Note: The Mystery of the Jewel was renamed and released as Ashes of Passion.

The Mystery of the Jewel

Realizing that producing his own features (as the Houdini Picture Corporation) and acquiring foreign films for distribution (as the Mystery Pictures Corporation) were losing propositions, Houdini finally brought his commercial film career to a close.

Source:

  • Houdini The Movie Star Film Notes by Bret Wood
  • The Secret Life of Houdini by William Kalush and Larry Sloman

A Look back at 2014

2014 was an amazing year for Harry Houdini Circumstantial Evidence (HHCE) for a number of reasons:
William Bennet the MirrorRep and HHStarted the year off with a post revealing a name for the representative from the Mirror.

That led to the folks at Handcuffs.Org doing a full scale search for the man.  Click on the link below and type William Bennett [aka William A Bennet and William Gray] in the Search for box and hit Go!.

Campbell and Grey Cheapside Handcuff PhotosSpeaking of handcuffs, I did a number of blogs on handcuffs in 2014:

Attended a number of excellent Houdini events with fellow Houdini “Nuts”:

haunted houdini 1 (1)Malibu Playhouse Flim Flam

Discovered and revealed several rare photos of Houdini in Hollywood:TMPW June 14 1919 WH HHHH Human Chain

Discovered and shared some fascinating information on Whitehead:whitehead

Set the record straight on some fallacies WRT Houdini:houdini smoking

Shared some incredible Grim Game ads, photos, and not widely known info about Houdini and the movie:airplane-collision-in-the-clouds

Shared some incredible Master Mystery ads, images, and not widely known info about Houdini and the movie:filmfun346356lesl_0374

Shared some incredible Terror Island ads and not widely known info about Houdini and the movie:amazing-under-water-scenes

Uncovered a 1926 railroad time table that may show the details of Houdini’s overnight train ride from Montreal to Detroit on October 23-24:1926 TimeTable Montreal to Detroit

Help unfold the Double Fold Milk Can Mystery:HofF Milk June 1980

Mentioned numerous times by John Cox at his Wild About Harry (Houdini) blog and Facebook pages:

Last but not least, my son got married in 2014 to a beautiful girl.

I am truly blessed and look forward to 2015, when hopefully we all get to see the Grim Game:

298-27 Sphinx Sept 15, 1919 v18n7 (L302-27)

L302-14

Enjoy the rest of 2014 and see you next year.

Body of Harry Houdini lying in state at the West End Chapel?

97265995

(Photo by Hank Olen/NY Daily News Archive via Getty Images)

Caption:UNITED STATES – NOVEMBER 04 1926: Body of Harry Houdini lying in state at the West End Chapel.

Above is an image that is reported to be the body of Harry Houdini lying in state at the West End Chapel.

Houdini died at Detroit, Michigan on October 31st, 1926.  His remains were prepared for burial by W.R. Hamilton & Company of Detroit and forwarded to New York City, where they were received by Samuel Rothschild on November 2nd, 1926.  For two days they lay in state in Mr. Rothschild’s establishment, the West End Funeral Chapel.

Rothschild and Sons West End Funeral Chapel

Rothschild and Sons West End Funeral Chapel

If we compare the New York Daily News photo with the photo below that appeared in a morticians trade magazine captioned as being Houdini at the West End Funeral Chapel (this photo also appears in The Secret Life of Houdini), they don’t appear to be the same casket.

houdiniincasket

(Photo courtesy of Houdinitribute.com)

Is Houdini in either of these caskets?

What about the casket being lowered into the ground at Machpelah Cemetery on November 4, 1926. which is our last look of Houdini on earth?

houdini casket

(Photo courtesy of Historic Films.com via WildAboutHoudini.com)

 

HARRY HOUDINI HURT DURING ACT IN THEATER

88 Years ago yesterday, HARRY HOUDINI HURT DURING ACT IN THEATER

Albany, October 12, [1926](By U. P.)  – Harry Houdini, the magician, has an incomplete fracture of one of the bones of the left foot, received last night when a 200-pound weight slipped and fell on his foot during one of his acts.  The muscles of the foot and other bones also were badly bruised, but his manager said today Houdini would appear at the theatre tonight, as usual.

Wood to Frikell Correspondence WRT Accident

This surprising communication was received by Samri Frikell [AKA Fulton Oursler] from Mrs. Wood, a medium, shortly after the accident to Houdini.

Three years ago, Doctor Hyslop: [meaning the spirit of Doctor Hyslop –Editor] said to J. Malcolm Bird of the Psychical Research Society: “The waters are black for Houdini,” and he predicted that disaster would befall him while performing before an audience in a theatre. Doctor Hyslop now says that the injury is more serious than has been reported and that Houdini’s days as a magician are over! [Spirit Mediums Exposed By Samri Frikell]

First off, I put very little stock in this weird prediction by Mrs. Wood. But what I find interesting is the ad attached to the prediction that describes Houdini getting hurt when a weight is dropped; There is no mention of the Water Torture Cell.

usdfull copy

Image courtesy of “The Key” by Patrick Cullition

I always heard the accident described this way:

While performing at the Capital Theater in Albany, New York, Houdini was being locked in the stocks and preparing to be hoisted upside-down over the Torture Cell.  But just as he was being raised from the stage, one of the cables loosened and twisted, causing the heavy stocks to shift and fracture his ankle. [WildAboutHoudini]

Another ad collaborates the 200 pound weight falling on his foot:

The_Evening_News_Tue__Oct_12__1926_HH

Houdini, Magician, Hurt When Weight Is Dropped

ALBANY, Oct. 12. – Harry Houdini, magician, who began a three day engagement at a theater here last night, suffered a painful injury to his left foot during the first performance. An X-ray examination today revealed an incomplete fracture of a bone and bruises to bones and muscles.  A 200 pound weight fell on his foot.  [The Evening News (Harrisburg, Pennsylvania) 12 October 1926]

Silverman describes the accident as follows:

As Houdini was being hoisted upside down from the stage into the Water Torture Cell, during act 2, the cables twisted or swayed. The lurch cracked the clamped footstock and fractured his left ankle.  In one sense he was lucky. A physician later told him that if the stock had not broken it would have amputated his foot. Unable to stand on his left leg, he omitted the Upside Down but continued the show. The injured foot bandaged by a doctor backstage, he gave his act 3 anti-Spiritualist demonstration from a chair. With the aid of a splint and a leg brace he got through two more days of performances in Albany and three in Schenectady before opening in Montreal.

How would you describe the accident?

Special Thanks to Lisa Cousins for showing me the Magic Castle’s copy of Spirit Mediums Exposed By Samri Frikell which led me to get my own copy of the magazine.

UPDATE: Check out post by John Cox that gives Houdini’s version of the Albany accident.

UPDATE2:

Here is another account of the accident that goes with the image (i.e., ad) from The Key above:

Six inches, three seconds and the goddess of luck last night saved Houdini, master magician, from an injury which would have left his physical prowess only a memory.

When the heavy wooden frame binding his feet loosened as he lay flat on his back on the stage of the Capitol theatre, the vise-like snap of the stocks fractured his left foot.  He was being lifted by the shoulders for the beginning of the Chinese Water Torture Cell trick.

In another three seconds he would have been free of the stage.  Had the frame loosened then, its snap would have severed his leg.  Dr. Elwynn Hannock, who attended him, said today, Or had the frame struck his leg six inches higher, it would have snapped his leg, he said.

Houdini plays today and tonight.  When the foot is better, he will try the Chinese trick again.

UPDATE3:

There wasn’t a counter weight.  I found an article by Houdini Himself, in the January 1919 Strand Magazine where he states:

“It is this element of danger that makes my Chinese torture-cell a good trick. Before doing the trick the audience sees the narrow glass case filled with water and my legs clamped with a three hundred and fifty pound weight.  It then watches me as I am lowered, head downward, into the water.  In sight of the audience the case is then locked and closed.”

hhcellprep

Image courtesy of houdinitribute.com

UPDATE4:

The Key has a photo with a caption that reads:

“Kukol handles the block and tackle while Vickery and Collins prepare to guide Houdini into the cell.”

The Key also says:

that Houdini laid flat upon his back on a mat resting on the stage floor while his assistants and members of the volunteer committee clamped down the stocks-shaped cover of the Cell upon his legs.  Ropes lowered from the flies were then hooked on to the corners of the cover securing Houdini, and by means of a windlass in the wings the cover was slowly raised until Houdini was suspended head-down, directly above the transparent and water-filled Cell…

It appears that the weight referred to in Newspaper accounts, is really referring to the stocks-shaped cover.

 

Has Houdini lost his marbles?

HH playing Marbles

The above item just recently sold on eBay for $1,115.00; It had 42 bids and 11 bidders.

The description of the item was as follows:

Another Large Album we are breaking up…Mostly Early Entertainment Personalities….Keep an Eye out since there are about 300 signed Pages ….

This album page is 10×13 with a 6 x 4 vintage page which is signed by Harry Houdini

Signed in fountain pen….I believe it reads….Yes Siree and like you are rustling this off in a Hurry…..Houdini   Jan.1925

Almost looks like Harry Houdini….Signature shows some wrinkling from gluing on the page…

I am doubtful if the signature can be removed…Certainly can be cut out or also simply left alone….

Newspaper or magazine images enhances the album page…

Also included the second page in the album after the signature entry which is a newspaper clipping about Houdini….

Begging to be framed……

Although, I suspect the main interest and value in this piece is Houdini’s handwriting and signature, I actually find the clipping of Houdini playing marbles, to be of much greater interest since I don’t believe that I have seen that image before.

HH playing Marbles w Boston Champion

It is an image of Harry Houdini playing an Exhibition Game with Jack Walkenstein, the Greater Boston Champion.

I tried to locate the clipping in online databases, but to no avail; if anyone knows where that image appeared, please let me know.

Congratulations to the winner!

Atlantic City Miracle Fallacy

 

Conan Doyle (Far Left) and Family, Houdini (Center) and Lady Doyle (Far Right)

Conan Doyle (Far Left) and Family, Houdini Center and Lady Doyle (Far Right)

On June 17, 1922, Houdini and Bess joined Conan Doyle and his family for a weekend break at the Ambassador Hotel in Atlantic City, a then popular family resort some 125 miles down the coast from New York.

During the weekend, Lady Doyle gave Houdini a private sitting, where she endeavored to obtain for him a message from his beloved mother, by means of automatic writing.

According to Sir Arthur’s account, Houdini himself requested this sitting; according to Houdini’s, it was volunteered by Lady Doyle. Whatever may be the truth concerning this, the fact remains that Lady Doyle gave Houdini a sitting, in which “messages” were obtained, claiming to come from his deceased, or, as he would say, “sainted” mother.

What mistake(s) did Lady Doyle make when she supposedly contacted Houdini’s mother during their Atlantic City séance in 1922?

A. Lady Doyle made the sign of the Cross

B. Lady Doyle wrote in English

C. Lady Doyle failed to mention the fact that it was Houdini’s mother’s birthday

D. A and B

E. A, B and C

Let’s look at the evidence for the answer.

Below is a reproduction of the first two pages of the “automatic message written by Lady Doyle at the sitting which she gave for Houdini in an effort to communicate with his mother that clearly shows the sign of the Cross and that she wrote in English.

Lady Doyle Automatic Message First two pages cropped

When, he saw the Cross on the top of the paper, and the lengthy message in English which followed, he at once became convinced, in his own mind, that it certainly did not emanate from his mother, but rather from the subconsciousness of Lady Doyle herself.

That’s two mistakes in Houdini’s mind, but what about not mentioning mama’s birthday. Describing the Atlantic City “miracle” in A Magician among the Spirits (1924), Houdini said:

“I especially wanted to speak to my Mother, because that day, June 17, 1922 was her birthday.  If it had been my Dear Mother’s Spirit communicating a message, she knowing her birthday was my most holy holiday, surely would have commented on it.”

Sounds reasonable, except for the fact that the séance took place on the eighteenth of the month and her birthday was really on June 16th, so the answer is D (Lady Doyle made the sign of the Cross and wrote in English).

grave marker cecilia weiss

Sources:

  • A Magician Among The Spirits (1924)
  • Houdini and Conan Doyle (1932)